Montanans Warned: Old Home Listing Photos Could Be Putting Your Privacy at Risk

Here in Montana, privacy isn’t just a preference; it’s part of who we are. We like our space, our quiet, and knowing the people down the road are keeping an eye out, not snooping in. That’s why it’s unsettling to realize that one of the biggest threats to our privacy might not be someone driving by, but someone scrolling through your old home listing online.

A new nationwide study uncovered something that’ll make you think twice before shrugging it off. Homeowners across the country are realizing that those once-innocent real estate photos might be exposing more than they’d like. In fact, 83% of homeowners say state laws should force real estate websites to delete photos once a sale is complete.

When a Zillow Scroll Turns Into a Security Risk

We’ve all fallen down the Zillow rabbit hole at some point. Maybe you were checking out what homes are going for in your town, or maybe you were just daydreaming about that log cabin on the Lake. But here’s the part most of us don’t think about: those same photos that make us say “wow” could also be giving strangers a detailed look inside someone’s home, maybe even yours.

READ MORE: The Best (and Worst) Parts of Living in Big Sky Country

Tony Gilbert, founder of the real estate marketing firm Hypewired, put it bluntly: “These aren’t just pretty pictures for Zillow anymore. They’re blueprints of where families sleep, store valuables, and raise children.” And when you think about it, he’s right. Listing photos show everything: your floor plan, the size of your windows, even where the back door is. Once those photos are online, they can linger for years, long after the house is sold and a new family has moved in. It’s unsettling to think about how easily a simple click can become an open invitation into someone’s private space.

When Old Photos Become a Criminal’s Roadmap

The numbers in this new survey are enough to make any homeowner uneasy. Out of 2,000 people surveyed, 69% said privacy is their top concern, and another 69% said safety. Law enforcement agencies across the country have already warned that burglars are using real estate websites to scout for potential targets.

Even more concerning, the FBI’s Boston office has linked outdated listing photos to a rise in online rental scams. Scammers are grabbing old home photos, reposting them on fake rental sites, and tricking innocent people into sending deposits for places that don’t even exist. As Tony Gilbert put it, “That’s not hypothetical. It’s happening right now.” And the scariest part? Those photos could still be floating around the internet, tied to your old address, without you even realizing it.

Parents-to-Be Are the Most Worried of All

Out of everyone surveyed, one group spoke the loudest: expectant parents. Eighty-seven percent of them said states should require old listing photos to be removed after a sale, and honestly, that’s easy to understand. As Tony Gilbert put it, “When you’re preparing to bring a newborn into the world, you think about safety differently.” The last thing any parent wants is photos of their home, especially their child’s room, still floating around the internet long after they’ve moved in.

Who Really Owns the Photos of Your Home?

Here’s the big question that’s got homeowners talking: once a house is sold, who should have the final say over those photos? Most people, about 61%, say the new buyer should get to decide. After all, it’s their home now, and they’re the ones living in it. But only 23% think the seller should have that power, 8% trust real estate agents to handle it, and just 3% say MLS associations should be in charge. “Once you buy a home, you expect to own the photos too,” Tony Gilbert said. “But right now, that’s rarely the case.”

Why Those Old Photos Never Seem to Go Away

So why do those old listing photos keep popping up long after the house is sold? The answer’s simple: money. Real estate sites like Zillow, Realtor.com, and Redfin thrive on clicks, and the more eyes on their pages, the more ad revenue they make. Those old listings still get plenty of traffic, which means your former kitchen or living room could still be racking up views years later.

Most people don’t realize that when they sign the paperwork to sell a home, they often give their agent or brokerage a “forever license” to those photos. That lets the industry legally keep them online, even when the house changes hands. The seller moves on without giving it a second thought, but it’s the buyer, the one actually living there, who’s left exposed. When you buy a home, you should be able to decide who gets to see inside it, not some website halfway across the country chasing clicks.

Could Montana Be Next to Push for Change?

If there’s one thing Montanans take seriously, it’s property rights and personal freedom, and this issue touches both. The idea that someone else can profit from photos of your private space just doesn’t sit right here. And while this latest push for change is starting in New York, there’s a good chance it won’t stay there for long.

As Tony Gilbert put it, “Consumers are saying loud and clear: balance marketing with safety, or we’ll demand laws to do it for you.” If lawmakers out east start cracking down on how long these photos stay online, don’t be surprised if states like Montana decide to take a stand, too. After all, protecting what’s yours is something we understand pretty well around here.

How to Protect Your Home and Privacy Right Now

If the thought of strangers scrolling through photos of your home makes you uneasy, there are a few things you can do to take control, starting today. First, ask your real estate agent to contact your MLS and request that the photos be removed once the sale is complete. Most agents can make that happen, but you have to ask.

Get our free mobile app

Next, reach out directly to the big real estate sites like Zillow, Realtor.com, and Redfin, and request that your old listing be taken down. They may not move fast, but persistence pays off. Finally, do a quick Google search of your address. If old photos still show up in search results, you can file a request with Google to remove cached versions.